As summer has arrived and temperatures rise, athletes in warmer climates may be thinking about how best to manage the challenges that hot weather brings. This is especially true for endurance athletes undertaking long-duration events where heat has time to take its toll. One of the biggest of these challenges is to prevent overheating and the performance-sapping effects of a rise in core temperature – something that can be achieved with various cooling strategies. Another is to ensure adequate hydration since even moderate water losses as a result of sweating can lead to a significant drop in performance (see this article). But while cooling and hydration strategies can mitigate much of the downsides of heat, there’s another aspect that can be more challenging – muscle cramps.
Despite being a very common condition in athletes, the exact causes of cramps have remained something of a mystery. What is known is that cramping occurs when the mechanisms controlling the electrical stimulation of muscle fibres (contraction - motor unit firing) and subsequent deactivation (relaxation) become impaired in any way. Physiological factors that have been investigated as possible contributors to this impairment of electrical control include.
● Inadequate hydration and insufficient levels of the electrolyte minerals in muscles;
● Poorly-trained muscles that are inflexible and/or insufficiently conditioned for the exercise being undertaken (muscle cramps are much more likely to occur in muscles that are unused to vigorous training).
● Inadequate rest and recovery; we know that muscles are much more likely to cramp when fatigued.
However, most authorities agree that ‘true cramps’ – those we normally associate with vigorous exercise, fatigue and dehydration/electrolyte imbalances etc - are caused by hyperexcitability of the nerves that stimulate the muscles, which also explains why much attention on preventing cramps has been focussed at minimising this excitability through optimum nutrition and conditioning protocols.
Studies on athletes investigating the causes of cramps have often produced mixed results. For example, research on ultra-distance marathon runners compared data from those who suffered exercise-induce cramps and those who didn’t to see how the runners’ electrolyte and fluid balance affected the risk(1). It found no difference in blood electrolyte concentrations and no alteration in hydration status in runners with ‘exercise associated muscle cramping’ (EAMC).
Despite the lack of rock-solid evidence however, most scientific authorities agree that any cramp-prevention strategy should at the very least aim to maintain adequate hydration – because all electrical signalling activity in the muscles takes place in an aqueous (water) environment and even small shortfalls in hydration levels could lead to impaired electrical signalling and an increased risk of cramping(2).
In addition, replenishing energy (carbohydrate) is important because even small drops in the level of stored muscle carbohydrate (glycogen) can lead to increased fatigue, which may in turn increase the risk of muscle cramps. Another area where most scientists agree is the value of stretching; good evidence suggests that a regular stretching program targeted at muscles prone to cramping can reduce the incidence of exercise associated muscle cramps as well as stopping cramp once it’s started(3,4). Passive static stretches held for 15-30 seconds at time seem to be most effective but the mechanism for this benefit is unclear.
It was almost exactly ten years ago that SPB reported on groundbreaking research showing the importance of the neurological system in the aetiology of muscle cramping. This backdrop to this story began when two avid sea kayakers sustained a serious episode of muscle cramps while winter paddling. However, it just so happened that one of these kayakers was a Nobel laureate in chemistry with a specialist interest in ion channel activation in the nervous system, while the other was a professor of neurophysiology at Harvard Medical School. To cut a long story short, they decided to dig deep into the mechanism of exercise-induced muscle cramps, and having eliminated electrolyte imbalances as a cause, decided to focus instead on the neurological dimension.
What they discovered was that muscles need to be ‘innervated’ to cramp effectively, implying the nervous system (not muscles) as a key element of muscle cramps. This discovery also raised the intriguing possibility that a ‘nerve block’ might be able to prevent cramps. The nerve block they had in mind was very novel - a strong sensory stimulus input into the brainstem and spinal cord in order to ‘shock’ the nervous system. Such a shock is able to activate proteins called ‘TRP ion channels’, which helps to tone down any overexcitability in the motor neurons that supply the muscles and which can lead to cramps.
They hypothized that a good way of delivering this strong sensory stimulus or ‘shock’ would be to use mix of ginger, cinnamon and capsicum from spicy pepper plants; by applying a strong sensory input and stimulating receptors in the mouth and oesophagus, the theory was that the pungent taste would overload nerve receptors, thus activating the TRP ion channels and producing a kind of numbing effect.
To confirm this, a number of carefully controlled scientific study was conducted, which showed that a) this spice combination was very effective at activating the TRP ion channels and secondly, was highly effective in preventing muscle cramping when taken before electric muscle stimulation (to induce muscle cramping)(5). Compared with findings in untreated participants, muscle cramp intensity and frequency was reduced 3-fold. Even better, this preventative effect was evident within minutes of taking the spice combination and lasted up to 8 hours.
The study above provided solid evidence for a powerful neurological element in muscle cramping. However, a follow-up study the following year by German researchers was somewhat less convincing. They used TRP activators to see if/how cramp threshold frequency (the level of electrical stimulation needed to produce muscle cramping), and cramp intensity (the amount of cramping as measured by electrical activity in the muscles) reduced following electrical stimulation on muscles in 22 healthy young volunteers(6). What the findings showed was that ingesting TRP activators resulted in a slightly higher resistance to muscle cramping (around 50% higher) after 15 minutes or so, but that this effect was more short-lived than in the study above, and had disappeared within about four hours. Meanwhile, when cramp did occur, there was no difference in cramp intensity or perceived pain between the TRP activated group and the controls.
Following this initial flurry of research into the neurological basis for muscle cramps, very little further research in this area was carried out subsequently, which means that scientists have remained rather unclear about definitive cramping mechanisms – and importantly how to prevent it. But has there been any further progress in determining how athletes can best prevent muscle cramping during exercise? Some researchers have revisited the original approach to this question – by tracking athletes in the real world undertaking a lengthy endurance event, seeing which athletes got cramp and which didn’t, then looking to see what factors might have explained the difference.
TAKE A RISK-FREE TRIALToday you have the chance to join a group of athletes, and sports coaches/trainers who all have something special in common...
They use the latest research to improve performance for themselves and their clients - both athletes and sports teams - with help from global specialists in the fields of sports science, sports medicine and sports psychology.
They do this by reading Sports Performance Bulletin, an easy-to-digest but serious-minded journal dedicated to high performance sports. SPB offers a wealth of information and insight into the latest research, in an easily-accessible and understood format, along with a wealth of practical recommendations.
*includes 3 coaching manuals
Get Inspired
All the latest techniques and approaches
Sports Performance Bulletin helps dedicated endurance athletes improve their performance. Sense-checking the latest sports science research, and sourcing evidence and case studies to support findings, Sports Performance Bulletin turns proven insights into easily digestible practical advice. Supporting athletes, coaches and professionals who wish to ensure their guidance and programmes are kept right up to date and based on credible science.